Original report pages 17–23.
(Appeared in The Ringing World, 7 April 1989)
The Central Council Survey of Ringing has found disturbing evidence of the number of silent towers in the British Isles, and of the number of ringers. Recent reports of an increased number of quarter peals rung suggest that the health of the Exercise is if anything improving, but if there are lots of towers without ringers and more where there are insufficient to ensure that the bells are heard every Sunday, then there is cause for concern which the Council, its affiliated bodies, and all ringers must face up to. In this latest article drawing on the Survey, members of the Committee report on the amount of ringing at the time of their investigation last November.
The Survey received responses from 300 tower captains, the individuals responsible for organising ringing at the selected churches. Of them 69 per cent reported that the bells at their tower were rung on the surveyed Sunday - 20 November 1988 - but only 52 per cent responded that those bells were rung every Sunday; a further 19 per cent reported that the bells were rung on ‘most Sundays’, 11 per cent that they were rung on ‘at least one Sunday per month’, and the remainder that they were rung ‘less frequently than monthly’. Since less than eighty per cent of the towers in the British Isles have a tower captain who could respond to the Survey (as reported in our preceding article - The Ringing World, 10 March 1989: Chapter 4) this means that the bells are heard every Sunday from less than half of the towers which contain rings of 5 or more. This can hardly be considered a healthy state of affairs.
When do they ring, and how often? Conventional wisdom has it that bells are rung for two services each Sunday, but of the 300 tower captains, only 57 reported that the bells were rung on more than one occasion on 20 November, twice in 55 cases and three times in the other two. The bells were heard once only from 152 of the towers and were silent in 91 of the 300. In most cases the ringing was for one of three services: matins (37 per cent of occasions); parish service/communion (35 per cent); and evensong (25 per cent).
How many bells were rung, and how many people turned up to ring them? Table 5.1 answers the first question. In total, all of the bells were rung at just 55 per cent of the towers where the bells were heard on 20 November 1988. Only at the 6- and the 12-bell towers did all the bells get rung in a majority of cases; whereas all were rung in 74 per cent of the 6-bell towers, for example, this was so in only 30 per cent of the 10-bell and 38 per cent of the 8-bell towers.
p. 18 Turning to the number of ringers who attended, Table 5.2 shows the percentages according to the number of bells in the tower. The average turnout was between 6 and 7, a figure achieved at none of the small number of 5-bell towers reporting but at all but one of the 12-bell towers. A double-digit turnout was a rarity, however, occurring on only 16 per cent of the reported occasions when ringing took place on 20 November 1988. Only one of the 5-bell towers had more ringers present than there were bells to be rung, and although three-quarters of the 6-bell towers had sufficient ringers present for all 6 to be rung, there were extra ringers present at 40 per cent of those towers only. Only at the small number of 12-bell towers was it the norm to have several more ringers than bells to be rung.
But how many ringers were present relative to the number who could have turned up? In Table 5.3 we give the number present according to the number in the local band. (The eagle-eyed will note that in the first row of that table we show that in 73 per cent of the towers with 4 or less members in the band the turnout was greater than 4; the reason is that visitors were present.) In general the figures suggest only low turnout rates. Thus in half of the towers with bands comprising from 9 to 12 ringers, for example, turnout was of 6 or less; of those bands with 13 or more members only one-third mustered a turnout of 9 or more. The average turnout, as a percentage of the band size, was about 55 per cent.
The overall picture is somewhat depressing, therefore, for these data do not indicate that towers are bursting with ringers on Sundays. The position is best, it seems, in the 6- and the 12-bell towers, and least healthy in the others. But there is very little room for complacency, for if the evidence of 20 November 1988 is anything to go by, the majority of those towers which have bands of ringers are struggling to make their bells heard on Sundays.
And what do they ring? We asked the tower captains what was regularly rung at their towers on Sundays, with the results presented in Table 5.4. Not surprisingly, the majority of tower-captains reported regular ringing of rounds and call-changes, but only one type of method-ringing - Plain Bob - was reported as occurring at even half of the towers. In general, the larger the number of bells available, the larger the percentage of towers where the more ‘advanced’ methods were regularly rung, as is very clear with both Stedman and Surprise. We leave it to readers to judge whether the absence of regular method-ringing from nearly half of the towers whose captains responded to the survey is disappointing - after all, the great majority (93 per cent) of our them agreed with the statement that ‘Well-struck call-changes are preferable to less well-rung methods on Sundays’.
Is the picture any different on practice nights? Of the 295 tower captains responding to the relevant question, 82 per cent reported a regular practice at their tower, although the figure varied from 67 per cent of the 24 5-bell towers, through 80 per cent of the 6-bell towers and 86 per cent of the 8- and 12-bell towers to 100 per cent of the 10-bell. Over three-quarters of the towers holding practices do so p. 19 weekly throughout the year. We shall have more to say about practices in a later article.
Finally, what about the recruitment and loss of ringers? We asked our respondents three questions about this. First, we asked how many ringers had left their bands over the previous twelve months, either moving to another tower (locally or elsewhere) or giving up ringing altogether. Table 5.5 shows that just over one-third of all towers lost ringers who moved, with a slightly larger percentage losing ringers who unfortunately gave up the Exercise; the latter totalled 211 individuals. Against this, we also asked how many proficient ringers had moved to the towers, how many learners had been recruited, and how many of the recruited learners were still ringing. Table 5.5 shows that about one-quarter of towers received ‘immigrants’ and that two-thirds recruited learners during the previous twelve months. Some 640 new learners took up ringing, three times the number who were lost, although of the 640 only 494 were reported as still active. Thus, there was almost certainly a net gain in the number of ringers over the year at the sampled towers whose captains responded to our questionnaire.
Of course, these figure refer only to the towers where ringing was taking place at the time of the survey; they exclude those where there may have been ringing a year ago but there is none now, and which have presumably contributed a net loss to the Exercise (some, but almost certainly not all, of the ringers at a tower where the bells have become silent may have transferred to another). So the net gain figure is no cause for complacency. What the Survey is showing very clearly is not only a large number of silent towers but also a large number of others where there are insufficient ringers able to turn out on an average Sunday and ensure that all of the bells are rung.
p. 20
Chapter 5 Tables
The report does not explain the asterisks. They mark impossible combinations: more bells rung than the tower has.
p. 21
p. 22
p. 23
In the original the number of ringers involved is printed in brackets after the All Towers percentage. Here it has a column of its own.