6  Ringers and the Church: What the Survey Tells Us

Original report pages 24–26.

(Appeared in The Ringing World, 21 April 1989)

Bellringing didn’t get very good treatment in The Archers recently. Shula Hebden was having matrimonial difficulties, and her husband Mark didn’t approve when he came home one evening to find she’d gone off to ringing practice. She told Tom Forrest she’d have to give up ringing, because there were too many demands on her time. (One of the members of the Survey Committee did not tell the reporter from The Observer that Shula should have put ringing before her marriage, however!!) And then, when Jack Woolley volunteered to learn to take her place, the new vicar of Ambridge told him that he wasn’t interested in the picture postcard aspects of church life, and wanted him in the congregation not in the belfry. Jack persisted, and the other ringers tried to put him off because he has a heart pacemaker; intriguingly, it seems that at Ambridge they run a ‘closed band’ with a fixed number of ringers only, and advertisements when there is a ‘vacancy’.

Shula and Mark’s marital difficulties are not our concern; nor are the peculiarities of the organisation of ringing at Ambridge (which, we believe, is within the territory of the Four Shires Guild) though we do hope that ringers with pacemakers will not be put off. But the views of the clergy on ringing and ringers are of significance to us. What do the clergy think about ringing; what do they know about it; and what other roles do ringers play in church life? These were some of the questions addressed in the recent Central Council Survey of Ringing, and here the members of the Committee tell us what they discovered.


As part of the Survey, nearly 500 members of the clergy were interviewed, over the telephone, about ringing at the sampled towers, and about their relationships with ringing and ringers. We cannot assume that they are representative of the clergy as a whole, since it may be that the clergy at churches with rings of bells differ in some ways from those at churches without bells - though we know of no reason why they should. All that we can report here are the responses of some 480 clergymen.

One major finding is that although the great majority of them believe that bells form an important part of church life, the subject of bells and bellringing was rarely mentioned during their preparation for the p. 25 ministry. We asked them the following question:

Do you think that the use of church bells is

  • An important part of church life
  • An unimportant part of church life
  • An irrelevant activity?

Over 80 per cent agreed with the first statement, and only 1 per cent agreed with the third. (‘Well they would do, wouldn’t they!’, might be your response, since they knew the survey was being conducted by the CCCBR, but clergymen are not that easily led, are they?!) If it is an important part of church life, however, why is nothing about bells and ringing provided for people who are preparing for the ministry? Less than ten per cent reported being given any information about the role of bells in church life during their training.

Of course, some of them are ringers themselves, but not that many. Of those interviewed, 14 per cent are currently active bellringers. A further 19 per cent had at some time been ringers, but had since given up. Most of the active ringers learned before they were ordained, so if we want more ringing clergy, the message is apparently that we should get more ringers into the clergy rather than the other way round.

And what is the relationship between the clergy and ringers? We have all heard the stories (some of them apocryphal, no doubt) about towers where the bells are not rung because of ‘unringable vicars’, and others about clergy who just don’t like bells. (And their families too; Mrs. Runcie was reported in a national newspaper a few years ago as not liking the sound of bells.) Our Survey didn’t identify any of these, as far as we could tell, but it did suggest that considerable numbers of clergymen could do more to integrate their ringers with other church activities. For example, among the towers where the bells are regularly rung on Sundays, only 11 per cent of the incumbents reported visiting the ringing room every Sunday (and quite a few of those who did were ringers themselves, anyhow); 35 per cent said that their visits were infrequent, and 8 per cent never visited the ringers. Similarly, less than 40 per cent regularly attended meetings of their ringers (they may not have been invited, of course, but presumably they hadn’t made it clear that they would like to be); about the same percentage ensured that the ringers were represented on the PCC (or similar body) and arranged special services so as to involve the ringers in other aspects of church life.

The picture we get is of relationships between clergy and ringers which are somewhat distant in many cases. Perhaps we need to ensure that the clergy know more about us, and are better informed about bells and bellringing. This could be especially valuable in the cases of bells that are either unringable or unrung on Sundays. How many clergy know about our ringing Associations and Guilds and the services they can offer? Of the incumbents surveyed who had ringable but unrung bells (on Sundays at least), only 41 per cent had initiated any attempt to get ringing started. About 31 per cent had been in contact p. 26 with a local Association with regard to assistance with ringing at their church, and in just over half of those cases assistance with training a band had been discussed. Over three-quarters of those who had been in contact with an Association had found it helpful, and none responded that it had been unhelpful. Only a third of those incumbents had made the initial approach to the Associations, however, suggesting that the latter may have to be more assertive in making their existence and ability to help known to the clergy - in the absence of such information being part of the basic training provided by the church.

Of course, there is also the opposite side of the coin; what other roles do the ringers play within the church community? Again, there are many stories of clergy who demand that their ringers attend services (twice a Sunday in some of the tales) and who don’t allow the non-attenders to continue as ringers; many of these apply to churches where the ringers who leave must do so in full view of the assembled congregation, which can be embarrassing to the incumbent, to say the least. But only 5 per cent of the incumbents questioned impose any rule about ringers’ attendance at services.

Perhaps they don’t need to, because the ringers go in any case. Of the tower captains interviewed in the survey, 59 per cent indicated that they attend services regularly in the churches where they ring, and the survey of individual ringers showed that exactly half are regular attenders. So, if there are 41,000 ringers or thereabouts, as we suggest, then about 22,000 are swelling the congregations.

In the mid-nineteenth century ringers were brought into the church as part of the Oxford Movement. The ‘secular sport’ about which Bill Cook has written in Change Ringing, Volume 1 was ended. Associations were founded to promote the acceptance of ringers as church workers and to bring about the integration of church and ringing room. The clergy now generally accept the importance of bells in the life of their church (as did the small sample of people attending morning service at Sheffield Cathedral when they were surveyed by Radio 4 on 12 March), and most ringers are active members of their church.

But much more can be done to ensure that the clergy are aware of the valuable musical instruments in their towers, of the keenness of ringers to ensure that those instruments are cared for and used, and of the existence of ringers’ associations that can help in a great variety of ways. If, as the results of our Survey are showing, there are weaknesses in ringing at the present time, then perhaps even closer ties between ringing associations and the churches are called for. More peals and quarter peals, and the largest-ever entry for the National Twelve-Bell Contest, are indications that in some ways ringing is healthier than ever. But with more than a third of towers silent on Sundays and with the situation at many of the others that insufficient ringers attend to ensure that all of the bells can be rung, these Survey findings suggest that there are other areas of the body needing urgent treatment. That treatment may need church:ringer cooperation to an extent not previously attempted.