24 Serendipitous Publicity: or How to Get on Radio 4 with Tom Forrest
Original report pages 102–104.
(Appeared in The Ringing World, 12 May 1989)
The Central Council Survey of Ringing was conducted in November 1988, and the first set of preliminary results was published in The Ringing World for 17 February 1989 (Chapter 3). This reported that approximately one-third of towers are silent on Sundays. The presentation was factual and neutral in tone; the final sentence merely stated ‘We leave readers to judge whether this is a healthy situation’.
This story was picked up by The Church Times, and a reporter spoke to John Baldwin on the following Friday. He suggested that they speak to me also, as I was analysing the data and could give more information. I was in London that day, and returned to Sheffield too late to return the call. I rang on the following Monday morning to be told: a) the reporter was on a week’s holiday; b) the story had gone to press; and c) they would be interested to receive material from us in due course.
The story appeared that week; it gave the impression that I had been employed as an academic consultant on the Survey.
The education and religious correspondent of The Observer picked up the story and decided to write a piece on it; her husband is a vicar (presumably at the church whose tower captain was pictured in her story). She rang John, but he was in Israel and Beryl Baldwin gave her my number. We spoke for about half-an-hour on the phone on the Thursday evening. She interpreted The Church Times story (she hadn’t seen The Ringing World) as indicating a crisis. I told her that the number of ringers was much as we expected, that we anticipated 25-30 per cent of towers being silent, and that since we had no earlier, comparable survey there was no base from which to argue that things had ‘got worse’. I did say that the tower captains’ survey was showing that recruitment was becoming more difficult and fewer people ‘stuck’ having learned; I speculated on possible reasons, such as the declining role of the church in modern society, and the greater range of calls on people’s time. We discussed the mentions of ringing on The Archers that week, but I DID NOT suggest that Shula should have put ringing before her marriage (!!). Throughout, I played down any ‘crisis’ mentality; there are still 41,000 ringers, other indicators (peals etc) show ringing in good health, and I was sure we would rise to the challenge of recruiting more ringers and getting more towers active. She rang me at work the next day, said she was going to run the story, and asked a few questions about the history of ringing and about peals - but didn’t use the material.
At 2100 on the Saturday evening, I was rung by ‘The World This Weekend’ team from Radio 4, who told me what was in The Observer, said they intended to do a short piece on it in their programme the next p. 103 day, and asked me to go to Radio Sheffield at 0930 to record an interview. I agreed, and went along briefed with our articles (the second had appeared by then, in The Ringing World for 10 March: Chapter 4) and computer print-out. I first did a brief interview for Radio Sheffield, which was transmitted the following morning. The Radio 4 interview was difficult, because they clearly wanted to present the situation as a crisis and I refused to be drawn either on that or on what they wanted me to say (‘people are more fickle’) about why people give up ringing: I only reacted strongly when they posed the likelihood of bells being replaced by machines. The item was broadcast at about 1350, and was introduced by statements of a dire crisis in ringing with towers closing every week almost, which was totally at variance with anything I had said. They used very little of the 10-12 minutes of interview with me, but some clips from The Archers of that week. (Colleagues now ring me to ask for updates on the series!)
After the interview, a reporter came to the Cathedral with me and recorded interviews with ringers (including some visitors from Nottingham and Newcastle: see The Ringing World, 2 June 1989) and with members of the congregation, some of which were used in the Radio 4 piece and others in the Radio Sheffield piece, with the bells in the background (all 12!). According to our niece who lives in Paris, the Radio 4 piece was also used on the BBC World Service.
On the following two days I was rung up by Radio Bedford, GMR (Greater Manchester Radio), Radio Leeds and by the Newcastle local paper. I agreed to record brief, factual interviews with each, explaining the nature of the Survey and its findings, and being positive and optimistic about the future. Each asked about their local area; I explained that the Survey was a national one and that I could say nothing about any local area. Several had already arranged interviews with local clergy, and in each case (using the Ringing World Diary) I put them in contact with local ringers. I have no idea what material was used. Later in the week I had similar contacts from Radio Bristol and Radio York (do the Sunday papers take longer to get there?; the Radio York reporter hadn’t heard of David Potter!). I was also contacted by a publisher in Wantage who was interested in producing a short, ‘popular’ book on ringing; by a religious affairs producer from Channel 4 who wondered if I might be in Winchester on March 19 so that Brian Redhead could interview me for a programme to go out on Maundy Thursday; and by a reporter from the US TV network CBS who is now planning a programme on ringing.
None of this publicity was solicited. All we had done was, at Chris Groome’s insistence, produce an early report in The Ringing World so that ringers could have some idea of our findings. In our article, and in all subsequent ones, we have not suggested crises but have used, in Chris’s words, measured tones. But the media, especially the national media (it is my impression that the local media were much less intent on dramatising the material), were intent on reading much more into the findings than we were - helped by The Archers story. We had issued no press releases, believing that would be premature.
p. 104 What did I (do we) learn?
That The Church Times is not necessarily immune to ringing stories, and does monitor The Ringing World.
That there is quite considerable media interest, which we could develop to our advantage.
That however well-prepared you are, and however measured your responses, if the media want to dramatise what you say, they will.
That, like it or not, status counts; that the Survey was apparently conducted by a Professor clearly impressed some media reporters.
That we should develop our contacts with The Archers.
The conclusion? All publicity is good publicity, except an obituary, and ringing isn’t about to die. I didn’t hear any of the local radio pieces, but feel we probably came out of them rather well; and there may have been other stations that didn’t contact me (or don’t like answer phones). We do have problems of recruitment, retention and motivation (sounds like the AUT and NUT) and the public coverage that we got cannot have done us harm; it may well have done us good.
Ron Johnston.