7  Teaching the Art: What the Tower Captains Say

Original report pages 27–34.

(Appeared in The Ringing World, 19 May 1989)

The future of the ringing exercise depends on a continued flow of recruits, who will take to the art and stick with it. So what is the present situation with learners and learning? To answer that question, we look at some of the responses to the Central Council Survey of Ringing from the tower captains, the people mainly responsible for ensuring that flow and for keeping the bells ringing.

A majority (63 per cent) of the 300 tower captains who provided usable responses had been elected by their fellow ringers, with 16 per cent appointed by the incumbent and a further 5 per cent by the PCC (or similar body). Most (66 per cent) were elected for an indefinite period, with a further quarter holding office before re-election for one year only. They bring to the task a wealth of experience in it, for on average those responding had been doing the job for over eight years; fully 14 per cent had been tower captain for an unbroken period of 25 years or more, and only 38 per cent had been in post for less than five years.

Recruitment

Of the 300 tower captains, 59 per cent reported that they had tried to recruit learners during the previous twelve months (the Survey was conducted in November 1988). And 67 per cent reported that new recruits had joined them during that period - clearly some towers obtained learners without having to go out and look for them! In one-quarter of those towers, however, there was only one recruit during the year, and in another quarter there were just two; only 30 tower captains reported more than five new learners joining their bands during the year in question. Most retained the interest of at least one; only 19 of the 201 reported that none of their recruits was still with them.

And is finding and keeping recruits harder now? Tower captains were asked whether over the preceding twelve months getting new learners had been ‘increasingly difficult’, ‘no change’, or ‘easier than previously’: 39 per cent thought the situation hadn’t changed, 44 per cent thought it had got more difficult, and only 9 per cent found it easier than previously. (The other available category for the answer was ‘no recruits necessary’, which was selected by 3 per cent of the respondents only!) They were also asked whether they found that recruits ‘are: increasingly likely to give up’, ‘are more likely to p. 28 stay’ or ‘don’t differ’ from previous generations: the answers were 25, 13, and 52 per cent respectively.

Overall, therefore, tower captains reported that they are finding recruits harder to get and harder to keep. Interestingly, the older the tower captain (and, on average, the longer she or he had been in post - 15 per cent of the tower captains are female according to the Survey) the greater the perceived difficulties. Whereas only 28 per cent of the 60 tower captains aged 20-39 found getting recruits increasingly difficult, the figure was 52 per cent for those aged 60-79 (of whom there were 63 among the respondents). Similarly, only 3 per cent of the younger group found that recruits are increasingly likely to give up, compared to 35 per cent of the older group. It may be that older tower captains for some reason find recruitment and training more difficult than their younger contemporaries, or it may be that they are remembering a golden age further back than the later generation can recall. (For further analyses of this point, see Chapter 17.)

In terms of recruitment, it was the 5- and the 12-bell towers that were least likely to have recruited new learners during the previous twelve months (Table 7.1). Of the towers that did recruit, the greater the number of bells the greater the number of recruits. Interestingly, the greater the number of bells the larger the percentage of tower captains who reported that it was becoming increasingly difficult to get recruits and (with the exception of the small number of 12-bell towers in the sample) the more likely that the recruits would soon give up ringing. This probably reflects the concentration of 10- and 12-bell towers in larger towns, where there are more alternative attractions and where declining congregations in many of the parishes provide only a small base from which to recruit; in the latter regard, the inner city churches face the same recruitment problem as many of the smaller rural parishes, where the majority of 5-bell towers are to be found.

Training

And what learning programmes do they provide for their active ringers? Most tower captains (82 per cent) reported holding a regular practice, usually once a week for part of the year at least. And of the towers that hold practices, 28 per cent report having additional special practices for learners, while 35 per cent allocate particular periods within the weekly practice for certain groups. In two-thirds of the cases, ringers are asked to learn special methods for a particular practice, but only 40 per cent of tower captains reported that they planned how they would conduct practices beforehand. The average attendance at practices over the previous three months was reported as 8, and in 73 per cent of the towers it was usually possible to ring all of the bells.

Not surprisingly, the situation varied somewhat according to the number of bells in the tower, as Table 7.2 shows. A regular practice was held at only two-thirds of the 24 five-bell towers whose captains responded to the Survey, compared to at least 80 per cent of towers p. 29 with six or more bells. The more bells in the tower, the more ringers who attended practice, on average - though in the cases of 10- and 12-bell towers the average attendance was less than the number of bells. Thus whereas it was the norm at most 5- and 6-bell tower practices to ring all of the bells, this was so at only a little over half of the towers which have 8 or more bells.

Who make the best recruits? The tower captains were given four age groups - under 15; 15-19; 20-39; and 40 or over - and asked which make the best and which make the least promising recruits. In general the older group was least favoured; only 13 per cent of those who nominated a ‘best’ group selected the over 40s, whereas 39 per cent identified them as the ‘least promising’. Those aged 20-39 were the most popular, with 35 per cent putting them in the ‘best’ group and 7 per cent only in the ‘least promising’. Opinion was most divided about the under 15s; 31 per cent thought they offered the best potential, and 32 per cent thought they offered the least! The respondents were also asked ‘which sex have you found better as recruits (in terms of rate of progress)?’: 7 per cent said males, 20 per cent females, and 66 per cent identified no difference.

How about the teaching process? Some 30 per cent of the tower captains reported giving their learners a set of goals and telling them what rate of progress they expected; 10 per cent had a chart on the ringing room wall recording individual progress. The band as a whole was set goals by 39 per cent of the respondents.

The Use of Books

What books do they use to help in teaching? The Survey gave tower captains a list of thirteen relevant to different stages of the learning process in ringing and asked which were used in their tower. It also asked whether learners were supplied with books, and if so which; whether they were encouraged to buy their own, and if so which; and which books the tower captains considered best for both learners and teachers. Table 7.3 gives the results.

Over half of the respondents indicated that two books - the Beginners’ Handbook and Diagrams - were used (that word was emphasised in the question) in their towers, with four more books being used in at least one-quarter of the towers. In over half of the towers, learners were provided with a book, with two books scooping the pool between them - the Central Council’s Beginners’ Handbook and Pam Copson’s One-per-Learner Book. In 66 of the other 126 towers learners were encouraged to get a book; the same two led again, but E.S. and M. Powell’s The Ringers’ Handbook came a strong third.

The tower captains were also asked what they considered the best books, separately for learners and for teachers (they could nominate up to two in each category). For learners, the Beginners’ Handbook won by a very short head from the One-per-Learner Book among the 401 nominations. Many fewer opinions were passed about the best book for teachers - perhaps indicating a market opportunity; A Tutor’s Handbook p. 30 was the clear winner, followed by two of the books in the Jasper Snowdon series.

Ringing Courses

How about attendance at ringing courses? Only a minority of the tower captains had taken part in any courses: 13 per cent had participated in at least one as a tutor, 28 per cent as a helper, and 24 per cent as a student. Just under half (49 per cent) reported that they encouraged members of their bands to attend courses; 69 per cent indicated that none of their members had attended a course in the previous year, while a further 11 per cent indicated that one member from their tower had attended a course. In all, 197 ringers from the 300 towers attended at least one course during the year - which suggests that in the British Isles as a whole just over 2000 ringers went on at least one course in the twelve months prior to our survey last November. (The figure is derived by grossing up from our sample towers to the total population: see our article in The Ringing World for 17 February 1989: Chapter 3. It will be checked in our later analyses of the responses from individual ringers and from Associations and their Branches: see Chapters 12, 13 , and 14.)

The tower captains were asked what they considered the most valuable topics for courses (they could nominate up to three), and Table 7.4 gives the outcome. Courses on teaching learners and bell handling, along with courses on ringing Plain Bob, were the most popular, suggesting that it is with the early stages of teaching ringers that tower captains most appreciate assistance; they also appreciate courses on teaching conducting and on bell maintenance. One-day courses were preferred by 44 per cent of the respondents; 22 per cent opted for half-day courses as the preferred length, with 17 per cent choosing evening courses. Only 4 per cent of the tower captains preferred courses lasting several days.

Ringing Standards

And what of the quality of the ringing? Tower captains were asked about the standard of Sunday service ringing over the previous twelve months. Their replies, in percentages, provide a generally optimistic picture:

Tower captains’ view of the standard of Sunday service ringing over the previous twelve months

Standard of Sunday service ringing Per cent
Improved considerably 15
Improved somewhat 32
Stayed about the same 40
Got somewhat worse 6
Got considerably worse 2
No answer 5

How can improved ringing, especially improved quality of striking, be encouraged? In many parts of the country, there has been a substantial increase in the number of striking contests for Sunday Service bands in recent years, and tower captains were asked their opinions of p. 31 these. Their replies (in percentages agreeing with the four statements) were:

Tower captains agreeing with statements about striking contests

Striking contests Per cent agreeing
Help to improve the quality of Sunday ringing 65
Help to build team spirit in the band 65
Are good fun but not to be taken too seriously 60
Are not in the spirit of church activity 18

These provide general endorsement for the contests. However, only 25 per cent of the tower captains reported that their bands had entered any contests during the previous twelve months. Of those whose bands did participate, 72 per cent entered only one during the year.

Local Ringing Associations

Finally, what of the relationships between the tower captains and the local ringing Associations? Most of the respondents (84 per cent) are members of a local Association; 39 per cent of them have held office at Branch level, and 22 per cent at Association level. But over a quarter (28 per cent) had attended no Branch activities in the previous twelve months, 15 per cent had attended just one event, and 12 per cent went to two. (Since 47 per cent reported that the local Association had held a meeting at their home tower during that period, it may well be, therefore, that many tower captains did not support any Association or Branch activity away from their home tower.)

Over three-quarters indicated that they encourage their ringers to join the local Association (28 per cent reported that members’ subscriptions were paid from tower funds), and 61 per cent encourage them to attend meetings. They were asked how many of their ringers are members of the local Association. The answers, as a percentage of the total, ranged from 0 to 100; 16 per cent of tower captains reported less than 10 per cent of their ringers being members but 30 per cent indicated that over 90 per cent are.

When asked whether they are satisfied with what their local Association does, 73 per cent of the tower captains answered yes. They were then questioned in more detail about four of the main activities of Associations - their ringing meetings, ringing practices, social events, and ringing courses - and asked whether they found what is provided as generally satisfactory or unsatisfactory, or whether they had no strong opinion. The answers are in Table 7.5. They indicate very little dissatisfaction, but substantial proportions who had no strong opinion to offer, especially about ringing courses.


A great deal of information has been presented here which it is hoped is of wide interest to all involved with ensuring the future health of the ringing Exercise. Further analyses will look at the responses of the individual ringers sampled in the Survey and at the activities of p. 32 the ringing Associations, to provide a rounded picture of the situation.

Chapter 7 Tables

Table 7.1: Recruitment by Number of Bells in the Tower
Number of Bells
Measure 5 6 8 10 12
Recruits (%) 46 70 68 73 50
Average Number 2.1 3.2 3.4 3.5 5.0
Harder To Get (%) 43 43 46 53 63
More Likely to Give Up (%) 17 26 26 40 0
Number of Towers 24 141 112 15 8

The first row in the table indicates the percentage of towers which had obtained recruits during the previous twelve months (46 per cent of the 5-bell towers, for example) and the second row indicates the average number of recruits in those towers which obtained any. The next row shows the percentage of tower captains who indicated that recruits were now harder to get and the last row the percentage who indicated that recruits were now more likely to give up.

Table 7.2: Practice Nights by Number of Bells in the Tower
Number of Bells
Measure 5 6 8 10 12
Hold Regular Practice (%) 67 80 86 100 86
Average Attendance 6.5 7.5 8.5 9.0 11.5
All Bells Rung (%) 94 87 56 57 57
Number of Towers 24 141 112 15 8

The % figures in the body of the table refer to the number of towers in the column total. Thus, for example, 67 per cent of the 24 captains at 5-bell towers reported a regular practice.

p. 33

Table 7.3: The Use of Books in Towers
Books Are (U, P, E); Best for (L, T)
Book U P E L T
Beginners' Handbook 60 39 32 20 4
Diagrams 50 1 0 4 16
One-per-Learner Book 35 36 20 19 1
Ringers' Handbook 30 6 15 8 9
Ropesight 27 1 2 3 10
Doubles and Minor for Beginners 26 1 2 2 4
Follow-on Book 23 6 0 5 2
A Tutor's Handbook 15 0 0 1 35
From Rounds to Bob Doubles 12 4 3 2 1
Conducting for Beginners 11 0 0 0 2
Tower Captain's Handbook 11 0 0 0 4
Towards Better Striking 6 1 0 0 1
Triples and Major for Beginners 5 2 0 0 0
Responses 300 174 66 401 140

Key to Columns: U - Used; P - Provided; E - Encouraged; L - Learners; T - Teachers. The figures in the body of the table are the percentages of the number of responses received from the tower captains. Thus, for example, there were 140 cases of a book being mentioned as ‘best for teachers’ (each respondent could nominate up to two), of which 35 per cent identified ‘A Tutor’s Handbook’.

p. 34

Table 7.4: Preferred Topics for Ringing Courses
Topic Per cent
How to Teach Learners 55
Ringing Plain Bob 46
Tower Maintenance 37
Teaching Bell Handling 36
Conducting 29
Ringing Rounds and Call Changes 27
Ringing Surprise Methods 11
Rope-Splicing 11
Tower Captaincy and Leadership 10
Ringing Stedman 4

The figures in the body of the table are the percentages of the tower captains who indicated that they found such courses among the most useful.

Table 7.5: Tower Captain Evaluations of Association Branch/District Activities
Activity Generally Satisfactory Generally Unsatisfactory No Strong Opinion
Meetings 63 8 20
Practices 57 9 22
Social Events 43 7 39
Courses 33 9 42

The figures in the body of the table are the percentages of the tower captains giving the reply indicated in the column heading. The percentages do not sum to 100 as some gave no response to the question.