11  Itinerant Bands

Original report pages 57–61.

(Appeared in The Ringing World, 16 June 1989)

The conventional view of the organisation of Sunday service ringing is that each tower has its own band of ringers who turn up once or twice every Sunday to ring for 30-60 minutes before a major service, usually Matins and/or Evensong. But this is not the situation in all parts of the British Isles. There are insufficient ringers available in some inner city areas to provide a separate band for each tower, for example, and joint bands which move from one church to another have been organised. In some rural areas, too, where parishes are small and livings have been amalgamated, there is a similar problem of sustaining bands of ringers at each church; again, the solution in a substantial number of cases is a combined band which provides ringers for several churches, perhaps not ringing at each on every Sunday but moving round them according to a rota. And then there are the towers which rely on others to provide their ringers on occasion, as with some Cathedrals which have a band provided by a different branch of the Diocesan Association on successive Sundays.

Just how common are such arrangements; how out of date are we in sticking to the traditional model of one-tower-one-band? Ron Johnston’s latest article based on the Central Council Survey of Ringing offers an answer.


Of the nearly 500 incumbents interviewed, 260 indicated that their bells were rung on the sampled Sunday (20 November 1988). In 36 per cent of the cases they were rung only once on that day. The incumbents were asked the composition of the band; four categories were offered, as shown in Table 11.1. The conventional model is correct for the large majority of towers - each has its own band of ringers. But the band is shared with other churches in 29 of the 260 cases, according to the incumbent.

In addition to the towers where the bells were rung on the sampled Sunday there were another 40 for which the incumbent reported that they were rung on most Sundays but not, for some reason, on 20 November 1988. Nearly half of those 40 have their bells rung by a band that provides the ringers for other churches too (Table 11.1). This gives a total of 47 towers out of the sampled 500, nearly 10 per cent of all towers, in which the band is shared with at least one other church.

p. 58 Where are they? Most reported shared bands operate at 6- and 8-bell towers (Table 11.2). But those are the most common towers in any case. The second set of figures - in brackets in the table - indicates the percentage of towers in each category reported as having a shared band; the highest figures, perhaps surprisingly, were for 8- and 12-bell towers, with 11 per cent of all 8-bell towers where the bells are regularly rung on Sundays relying on a shared band.

There is a clear north:south divide shown in Table 11.2. As many as one-in-six of all towers in the Southwest and Southeast were reported as having a shared band, compared with about one-in-seven in the Midlands: shared bands were much rarer in East Anglia and in the North of England, and none were reported in the Rest of the British Isles, undoubtedly because most of the towers there (with the exception of some parts of Wales) are considerable distances apart. With regard to settlement type, most shared bands are at village churches, but there are no significant differences between the different settlement types in the percentages with shared bands (the second figures in the table), although half of the small number of inner city towers were reported as having shared bands - which accounts in part at least for the large number of 12-bell towers with such an arrangement.

How many people are involved? Of the 300 tower captains who responded to the survey 45 indicated that they are responsible for the ringing at churches other than that for which they were questioned. This tallies reasonably with the incumbents’ returns, given that not all tower captains replied to our questionnaire. Most of the 45 organised ringing at one other tower only, though one was responsible for the ringing at a total of four others. Only just over half of them were also responsible for ringing at towers where the bells were rung on the surveyed Sunday (20 November 1988), however, so either their band does not visit every tower in its group on every Sunday or it has insufficient ringers to ensure ringing everywhere on every Sunday.

Of course, a shared band may have a separate tower captain for each tower; none of the respondent tower captains responsible for ringing at more than one tower is in charge at a 12-bell tower, for example. We also asked tower captains ‘Do you personally regularly ring at another tower on Sundays’, and 29 per cent replied yes, so more ring at several churches than are responsible for the ringing at several towers. Over half of those responsible for the ringing at a 5-bell tower and one-third of those in charge of ringing at one of the small number of 12s in the Survey also rang regularly at one or more other towers, for example. Ringing at another tower was particularly common among tower captains at the few inner city towers, and was much more prevalent in the southern than in the northern regions.

The tower captains were also asked how many times they rang on 20 November 1988: just under half rang once; 19 per cent rang twice; 7 per cent rang more than twice; and 23 per cent didn’t ring at all. Ringing on three or more occasions was most frequent among the small number of 12-bell tower captains; those associated with 8-bell towers were most likely to ring once only. Not ringing at all on the day was much commoner among those associated with 5- and 6-bell towers (42 and p. 59 26 per cent respectively), suggesting that one of the reasons may have been an insufficiency of ringers available. Regionally, non-ringing on the Sunday in question was commonest in East Anglia (45 per cent of all tower captains there) and rarest in the North of England and the Rest of the British Isles. (Interestingly, of those who reported that they regularly ring at more than one tower, 54 per cent rang only once on 20 November, compared with 46 per cent of those who ring at one tower only.)

Among the 1052 other ringers who responded to the Survey, 19 per cent also ring regularly at towers other than that from which they were sampled. They were asked if this is because their band provides the ringers for more than one church or because they are members of more than one band: 58 per cent said the former and 53 per cent the latter, with 28 per cent (6 per cent of all ringers) being both a member of a band that services more than one tower and a member of more than one band! Overall, about 12 per cent of all ringers are members of bands that staff more than one tower, and about 8 per cent are members of more than one band (with the latter presumably able to do so because the bells are rung at different times).

Nearly half of all the respondents from 12-bell towers reported ringing at other towers regularly on Sundays, as did 30 per cent of those from 10-bell towers and 28 per cent of those from the 5-bell towers; the figure for both 6- and 8-bell towers was 17 per cent. Ringing at more than one church is more typical of cities than of towns and villages; the figures for the five settlement types (see our article in The Ringing World for 7 July, 1989: Chapter 10) are - inner cities, 40 per cent; suburbs, 11 per cent; large cities, 39 per cent; towns, 16 per cent; villages 18 per cent. Of those who ring at more than one tower, three-quarters of those based at 5-, 6- and 12-bell towers reported that it was because their band serviced more than one church, whereas that was the case with only about half of the respondents from 8- and 10-bell towers (who are more likely to free-lance among several towers, it seems!).

When asked on how many occasions they rang on 20 November last, 43 per cent said only once, 16 per cent replied twice, and 5 per cent rang more than twice: fully 36 per cent of all the ringers surveyed did not ring on that day (and only very few volunteered the information on the questionnaires that they would have done but for the weather). Not ringing on the day was particularly prevalent in the case of ringers associated with 5-bell towers (66 per cent) and least common among those associated with 12-bell towers (21 per cent). There were no significant differences between regions in the turnout rate, but there were between the settlement types: in the villages, 42 per cent did not ring on 20 November and only 2 per cent rang more than twice; in the inner cities, 19 per cent did not ring and 44 per cent rang three times or more.

Editor’s note (2026)

The article of 7 July 1989 on settlement types is Chapter 9 in this book, not Chapter 10.

Of the ringers questioned, 63 per cent attended practice at their home tower during the week prior to the surveyed Sunday (which compares with 73 per cent of their tower captains). In addition, 26 per cent of them reported attending a practice at another tower during that week p. 60 (ringers from 5-, 10- and 12-bell towers were more likely to do this than were others; not surprisingly, ringers living in the Rest of the British Isles were least likely to). When asked why (they were given a list of four possible reasons, plus an ‘any other’ category) 40 per cent said it was because ‘ringing elsewhere helps to improve your ringing’; the other three reasons got similar levels of support (along with ‘any other’), with 17 per cent (over 4 per cent of all respondents) reporting that they were helping to train a band there.


In a large-scale survey, designed to identify general patterns, it is not possible to explore particular arrangements in detail; all that the survey can do is point to issues that need further research. The findings presented here clearly indicate a potentially fruitful area for future inquiry, and perhaps readers of The Ringing World can help by writing in and describing the situation where they ring. If a third or more of British Isles’ church towers with rings of five or more bells are silent, in many cases because of a shortage of ringers and potential ringers in the congregations and parishes that they serve, then perhaps a way forward to get more bells ringing is to get more joint bands organised. There is substantial experience already available on which to draw.

One further implication of what we have presented here is that our earlier estimate of the number of ringers in the British Isles (Chapter 4) may have been too generous because we did not take account of the amount of potential double-counting involved in the method used. Up to 20 per cent of the ringers surveyed in November 1988 as members of the bands associated with the sampled 500 towers could have been surveyed if a totally different sample of 500 had been taken, because they are either members of a joint band or are members of more than one band. Several ways of allowing for this double-counting have been tried now that these additional data are available, and suggest that the number of ringers in the British Isles may be much closer to that figure of one-per-bell (i.e. about 36,000) than we initially thought. The statistical niceties of the estimating procedures are of little relevance, however. What is important is that we need more ringers, and more ringers to ring at more churches; the former calls for recruitment drives, whereas the latter calls for mobilisation of ringers in an area to service as many towers as feasible.

p. 61

Chapter 11 Tables

Table 11.1: Nature of the Band
Band Rang on 20.11.1988 Did not ring on 20.11.1988
A regular band associated with that church only 87 52
A regular band that rings at that church and at others too 11 45
Visitors who don't normally ring at that church 1 0
Identity unknown to the incumbent 1 1
TOTAL NUMBER 260 40

The figures in the table are percentages of the column totals.

Table 11.2: Shared Bands by Location and Number of Bells
Classification / Category Per cent of shared bands Per cent of category with shared bands
Number of Bells
5 9 7
6 49 9
8 36 11
10 2 4
12 4 13
Region
Southwest 32 17
Southeast 36 17
West Midlands 13 14
East Midlands 13 13
East Anglia 4 4
North 2 2
Rest of B.I. 0 0
Settlement Type
Inner City 9 50
Suburban 9 9
Large City 4 9
Town 26 11
Village 53 12

The figures in the table are percentages. The first figure indicates the percentage of the towers with shared bands that are in the relevant category; the second (in brackets) indicates the percentage in that category that have shared bands. Thus, for example, 4 per cent of all shared bands operate in 12-bell towers, and 13 per cent of 12-bell towers have a shared band.

Editor’s note (2026)

In the original the second figure is printed in brackets after the first. Here each has its own column.