Original report pages 84–86.
(Appeared in The Ringing World, 27 October 1989)
Those who attended the Central Council Open Meeting at Birmingham in May 1989 will recall that one person present (not a member of the Survey Committee!) claimed that peal ringers (University graduates all, he said) are a major problem for the Exercise. They contribute nothing to the fundamental activity of ringing regularly on Sundays, he contended, and play no part in the important work of ringing Associations. Do you agree? Was he right? To see if peal ringers are the parasites on the Exercise that was so forcefully claimed, Ron Johnston has analysed some of the data from the Central Council Survey of Ringing questionnaire to individual ringers.
We asked the respondents (the sample of individual ringers, excluding tower captains) how many peals they had rung: of the 1014 who answered, 684 had rung none, 175 had rung between 1 and 10, 73 had rung between 11 and 50, and 82 had rung 51 or more. Our analysis focuses on these four groups (Table 18.1).
On one issue, the critic was clearly correct. We asked whether the respondents had attended a university, polytechnic or college (termed graduates in the table, although not all may be!). The answers show that the more peals you have rung, the more likely it is that you are a graduate.
But so what, if those intellectuals get more pleasure from peal-ringing than others what does it matter, if they ring on Sundays, go to practice nights, and support Association activities? And the next five rows of figures in the table show that they do. The more peals our respondents had rung, the smaller the percentage of them who didn’t ring on the previous Sunday (20 November 1988), the greater the percentage who ring regularly at more than one tower each Sunday, and the greater the percentage who go to other towers’ practices; furthermore, there were no differences between peal-ringers and others in attendance at their home practice.
Similarly with attendance at Association meetings: the more peals rung, the smaller the percentage who attended no meetings in the previous year and the larger the percentage who attended more than two.
Finally what about their attitudes. We asked respondents whether they agreed or disagreed with each of the following six statements:
p. 85
- A The important thing is that bells are rung on Sundays, not what methods are rung
- B Well-struck call-changes are preferable to less well-rung methods on Sundays
- C Most ringers are more concerned with learning methods than with striking properly
- D Peals do little to advance the quality of Sunday ringing
- E Too many ringers put peal ringing before the encouragement of Sunday ringing
- F Ringing has little part to play in modern church life.
On A, B and F there were no differences: all ringers are equally concerned to put the quality of ringing as the highest priority on Sundays, and agree on its relevance to church life, though on C we find the peal ringers most concerned about the lack of attention given to striking. On D and E, many more peal ringers identify its positive impact on Sunday ringing than do non-peal ringers (well they would, wouldn’t they! perhaps they would like to tell us why); peal-ringers also disagree with the contention that they give peal ringing too high a priority.
So, hands off the peal ringers, they are not the villains that at least somebody believes? The Central Council Survey of Ringing tells us so, so it must be right! We must enter a slight caveat, however. The Survey only covered those ringers who are affiliated with a Sunday service band. We’re told that there are some people who ring lots of peals but aren’t members of a band, and of course they would have slipped through our net. Perhaps there are lots of them (really!) and the criticism is valid. Among affiliated Sunday service band members, however, we give the peal-ringers a clean bill of health; in several ways, they are among the stalwarts of the Exercise.
p. 86
Chapter 18 Tables
The group labels in the first column, other than “Agreed with statement”, are ours; the original separates the blocks with space only. The groups are 684 ringers with no peals, 175 with 1-10, 73 with 11-50 and 82 with 51 or more (Chapter 18 text).